{The decision}

Randy sat me down at dinner, and said that he wanted me to keep both wedding rings.  He would find a way to pay the insurance company back.
My first thought...."No, no,....I can't"
My second thought...."What have I done to deserve this man?"
My third thought...."Well, ok....I guess 2 wedding rings would be just fine :)"

So the decision is:  I'm keeping them both.
YEA!!!!

Thanks for everyone's advise!